RIP Star Wars: 1977-2012


All right. I was going to write about another topic this week, but the news about Disney acquiring Lucasfilm and Star Wars is too big to ignore. My thoughts will probably change as the months go by, but here’s my gut reaction on the news:
First, you have to understand what Star Wars is to me. It’s an integral part of my life. It’s the reason I want to make movies. I watch Star Wars and have an emotional or intellectual reaction to it. Every time I watch it. Depending on what’s going on in my life at the time, sometimes I’ll have new reactions to the same films. I want to do that. I want to make movies that people connect with and react to like that. The money that comes with those movies comes second.
Second, I define Star Wars as the story of the rise and fall of Darth Vader. It’s a story rooted in human myth and history. It draws parallels and inspiration form all kinds of culture. It’s a saga rich with the human experience, which is what gives it its universal appeal. This is a saga about how a talented young boy is corrupted and rules the galaxy for evil, but finds redemption through his son and dies to reverse all the wrong he’s caused the universe.
Oh my gosh. That’s an amazing story to me. Before today, I often thought to myself about how that’s a story that will in turn become a part of mythological history like the inspirations it drew from. Wow. Wouldn’t that b e great? There would be this complete saga of films from centuries ago that spawned a change in the way films were made and gave children a new set of heroes and villains to grow up with.
I was also thinking, literally yesterday, about how the story is complete. I will agree with fans that say the Prequels were the weaker of the 6 films, but if you take a step back, they filled in the backstory and completed the story introduced in the Original Trilogy. Now it’s a complete story. Sure, there are always new games and tv shows. With the over use of powers in games like the Force Unleashed and introducing important, but previously unmentioned, plot points like Anakin having a Padawan or Darth Maul surviving The Phantom Menace in The Clone Wars tv shows, I think these newer media adaptations are missing the mark.
Why don’t Jedi in the movies just bring Star Destroyers out of the sky like in the game? Why was Obi-Wan’s confrontation with Darth Maul never mentioned in Revenge of the Sith, or Anakin’s Padawan for that matter? At the end of the day, though, it doesn’t matter because those aren’t the big dogs of the Star Wars franchise: the films. As far as canonicity goes, I have the films at the top of the list; they’re the core story. Video games, tv shows, and books are just other people’s interpretations of what could have happened in those blocks of time between films.
But Disney’s acquisition of Star Wars brings with it the announcement of an entirely new trilogy. People used to always ask me or tell me about how they’re trying to make another set of films, to which I’d reply I wouldn’t be excited for them since they wouldn’t be about the arc of Darth Vader. I’d laugh it off as something that wouldn’t ever happen, but secretly feared that it inevitably might. Until today. Now this is becoming a reality as they go further and further in development. Disney, I don’t care if you make more games and tv shows. Go right ahead. But leave the films alone! The story’s been told, and leave it at that. There are plenty of other avenues to expand on the Star Wars universe in.
But here’s the problem. This is Hollywood. This is Hollywood in the year 2012. Look at all the sequels and adaptations in theatres today. We’ve got The Hobbit coming out in a trilogy (do we really need that many 3 hour movies based on such a smaller book?), a 5th Paranormal Activity on the way with an official Spanish version in development, and reboots of franchises like Spiderman, a franchise who had a film in the last version come out only 5 years ago. Hollywood is out of ideas and they just want ideas they know they can take to the bank.
Star Wars came around in a time when the film industry was in a rut with boring or dark movies and it opened up a new door. It revolutionized the industry. It told studios that movies could be fun again! Now, it pains me to see it become a part of Hollywood’s latest rut: a disrespectful, sequel making machine that only cares about finding properties that will make them money, no matter what. The art of telling and preserving a story is gone. Closure isn’t a concept anymore. Closure is just a road block to making more money.
Like, it’s seriously giving me an existential crisis right now. For lack of a better phrase, my inspiration just went to the Dark Side. You can definitely argue that with a six film saga, including a Prequel Trilogy, that Star Wars was already a sequel making, money machine. Yes, it did exactly that. But it told its story, wrapped everything up, and was done. DONE! The fact that Disney just wants to tack some extra movies on the end for money, as everything’s about money in this business, is killing me. Is there anything else that even needs to be told?
That’s something I ask myself anytime I write something or someone passes me something to read. Why does this story need to be told? A lot of sequels and adaptations don’t really need to be told in theatres lately, at least not beyond the motivation to make money. For the sake of argument, I’ll agree that George could have made the original Star Wars and left it at that, as it was a complete story within itself. But every sequel and prequel after that had story elements that needed closure in an upcoming film. By the time all 6 were done, everything that needed to be told had been put on screen already. So what’s left for this new trilogy? Money. Just money.
I used to be proud of the fact that I was alive while they were still making Star Wars movies, but with this acquisition, it very well seems like they could keep churning out Star Wars movies for eternity. Every new movie will cheapen and discredit the original story George Lucas originally introduced in 1977. As much as I hate to say it, haters of the Prequel Trilogy will already agree with me that that’s happened, which I’ll acknowledge. Irvin Kershner, rest in peace, said that a sequel to something like Star Wars can only be that, a sequel. Empire Strikes Back proved him wrong, but I think this new trilogy will retroactively prove him right.
What happened to respect for a story? With this announcement, I don’t even know what the next 3 films would even be about. What about the countless books and games that already explore the time after Return of the Jedi with Luke, Han, Leia, and the others? If they’re somehow going to follow up on those characters, will they just dismiss all the Expanded Universe and make up something new? Or will they introduce a whole new set of characters, to which I would reply, why should I care about these people? They’re not what Star Wars is about. It’s about Darth Vader, and he died!
But with all the different ways Hollywood handles sequels and reboots nowadays, I know that I’m making a double standard here with Star Wars, like it’s something sacred and not to be touched, while I love other reboots of franchises. Well, I do believe that, but for the sake of argument, let’s explore it. The most obvious first choice to explore is Star Trek.
The original Star Trek followed the voyages of the human race in space exploration, particularly the crew of the USS Enterprise. Years later, they rebooted it with another tv series, Star Trek: The Next Generation. This one followed a different crew on a ship farther in the future. And more series and movies came along after that. Overall, it’s a successful series with amazing installments, with a couple weaker ones here and there.
Then in 2009 JJ Abrams rebooted Star Trek again with another film based on The Original Series. It featured a new style and story that set it completely apart from every show and film that came before it. And you know what, though I thought it was leaned more towards an action packed kind of film then the intellectual and moral kind of story the other films told, I forgave that difference and loved the movie.
But why am I not prepared to do this for the new Star Wars movies coming out? The answer’s in what the franchises are about. Star Trek is about space exploration and questioning of human morals as the crew of various Enterprises discover new forms of life. Every series and film stayed pretty much true to that theme. Star Wars is the story about the rise and fall of Darth Vader. You can’t make new stories based on that. There’s only one Darth Vader, and he’s dead. End of story. It doesn’t make sense to reboot like Star Trek does.
But what if they changed it stylistically like the new Star Trek did. That movie feels so different then the others, but it works. Why? Well, they pretty much gave themselves freedom to do whatever they want by putting it in a completely different universe then the TV show. Would that work for Star Wars? Could they write up another universe to give themselves even more freedom?
I don’t think it would work. In a franchise like Star Trek, where time travel and alternate universes are a normal occurrence on the show, an alternate universe makes sense. The stylistic differences are alright too since the shows and movies all had different writers and directors behind them. But the Star Wars franchise is different. Love or hate him, George Lucas and his close team give all the movies the unified feel that they have. Some are better then others, but they all feel the same since there’s a bunch of people who worked on all the films together. And not to mention that Star Wars is more about mythos then science fiction, so writing up an alternate universe wouldn’t fit in the idea of the franchise.
My last point is the conflict over how Disney can treat the franchise. On one hand, they could let it flourish like Marvel’s Cinematic Universe has under their ownership. Or on the other hand, they could stray away from the core ideas of the franchise just like Disney did when they took control of the Power Rangers franchise. I’d at least hope the films are good, but I don’t think they’d stick to the real Star Wars feel and style that the previous six have. But as I said before, good film or not, the complete Saga as is doesn’t need another movie to tell another story. There’s nothing else to tell that would respect the arc and closure in the Saga we already have.
Whew. Got that off my chest. I don’t know if any of that made sense or if it was even organized in an understandable way. But that’s how I feel right now, and all the above ideas have been rattling through my brain non-stop. Even keeping me up at night! Don’t worry about that, though. I needed to pull an all nighter to finish the first Hyperdrive Pictures video, so it actually ended up helping me in the long run.
And last note. Disney, don’t even think about putting a song and dance routine in the new movies. Seems like common sense, but I’m just gonna throw that out there.